Two offers with different prices can leave a Louisville seller with the same estimated proceeds. A useful comparison subtracts the costs and payoffs associated with each offer, then considers the conditions and timing separately.
The example below is illustrative only. It is not a Louisville price forecast, fee quote or valuation of your property. Replace every figure with information for your own sale.
Start with comparable assumptions
Suppose two proposed sales have the same $140,000 mortgage payoff for the example date. Assume the listed transaction and repair costs do not overlap with ongoing holding expenses, and ignore tax consequences for this simplified exercise.
- Offer A: $240,000 price minus $16,000 seller transaction and repair costs minus $140,000 payoff equals $84,000.
- Offer B: $228,000 price minus $4,000 seller transaction and repair costs minus $140,000 payoff equals $84,000.
The prices differ by $12,000, yet the estimated proceeds are equal under those assumptions. Neither example establishes what a particular buyer will charge or which route you should choose.
Now test the timing difference
If one route takes longer, calculate its additional non-overlapping carrying expenses. For example, two extra months at an illustrative $900 in recurring non-principal expenses would add $1,800.
Use the appropriate payoff for each actual date. Account consistently for principal payments, tax or insurance adjustments and escrow so that the same amount is not deducted twice.
Mark estimates instead of hiding uncertainty
Separate a written fee quote from an allowance for repairs that has not been assessed. Identify whether a buyer credit is agreed, requested or only a possibility.
Build a second version if a material assumption changes. Ask what happens if a repair costs more, completion is delayed or the buyer seeks a price change. Do not invent a probability to make one outcome appear certain.
Keep contract risk beside the numbers
Record funding evidence, deposit, inspection rights, appraisal or financing conditions and other deadlines. Have your agent or attorney explain the agreement’s meaning and remedies.
A higher estimated net amount can still come with conditions you cannot accommodate. Conversely, a cash offer may retain inspection, title or other conditions. Compare the actual documents.
Separate sale proceeds from tax profit and moving cash
The amount received at closing is not automatically your taxable gain. A tax adviser can review basis and other applicable rules. Your next-home deposit, moving costs or replacement appliances also affect how much cash remains available after the move.
Keep those categories visible rather than calling every subtraction a closing cost.
Use the worksheet on a real offer
Simply Sold can discuss a written as-is purchase proposal. Request an offer and compare it with a realistic alternative using verified costs, payoffs and terms.